Skip to content
Nobel Jews
Portrait of Robert W. Fogel
Photo: Michael Fogel, submission by Michael Fogel · CC BY-SA 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences · 1993

Robert W. Fogel

He used numbers to rewrite American history, from railroads and slavery to why people today grow taller and live longer.

The Nobel citation: “for having renewed research in economic history by applying economic theory and quantitative methods in order to explain economic and institutional change”
Born
July 1, 1927, New York, NY, USA
Died
June 11, 2013, Oak Lawn, IL, USA
Shared with
Douglass C. North
Affiliation at the time
University of Chicago, USA

Economics prize

1993

Shared with 1 other laureate.

Age that year

66years

Born in 1927.

Sources cited

23

Fact-checked September 24, 2026.

  • His parents were seven-year-olds in Odessa during the 1905 pogrom. In 1966 he tape-recorded their memories of the days when mobs attacked Jewish homes.
  • Typhus nearly killed his father on the family's way to America in 1922. A loan from the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society paid for their steerage tickets.
  • His railroad book argued that without railroads, the US would have reached its 1890 level of income only about three months later.
  • He estimated that better nutrition explained roughly 30 percent of the growth in British income per person between 1790 and 1980.
  • From 1982 he and his wife Enid, a Black youth leader he met in 1948, hosted a dinner every fall to welcome minority students to Chicago's business school.

The breakthrough

Counting the past: railroads, slavery and the changing human body

Fogel helped build cliometrics, named after Clio, the Greek muse of history: studying the past with economic theory, statistics and computers. His signature tool was the counterfactual, a careful what-if. To judge how much railroads mattered, he asked what the American economy of 1890 would have looked like without them. Think of a highway closing: you would not stop going to work, you would take side roads and arrive a little later. America had good side roads in its rivers, canals and wagons, so by his estimates railroads added only a few percent to national output. Growth came from many improvements added together, not from one miracle invention. With Stanley Engerman he turned the same methods on slavery. Using thousands of plantation records, probate files and slave-ship manifests, they concluded that slavery in the South was profitable and still expanding in 1860. It was not dying on its own; it took political decisions and a war to end it. Later he studied the human body as an economic record. Height and weight reveal how well people ate and how sick they were as children. Comparing national food supplies with records of people's heights and weights, he showed that many poor Europeans around 1790 were too small and underfed to do much work. Over three centuries, better food, sanitation and medicine made people taller, stronger and longer-lived. He called this technophysio evolution: a biological but not genetic change, carried forward by living conditions.[3],[4],[5],[10],[12],[13]

“We wanted to show traditional historians that they could ignore quantitative evidence only at their peril.”
Robert W. Fogel, Explaining, in a 2007 University of Chicago Magazine interview, why he and Stanley Engerman framed Time on the Cross as a challenge to traditional historians.[12]

What it meant for humanity

Fogel changed how people understand the past, and through it the present. He and his fellow cliometricians showed that census sheets, plantation ledgers, probate files and army records, long left unused because they seemed too massive to tackle, could be counted and tested, and that some things everyone knew were wrong. His railroad study left a lesson economic historians still repeat: no single invention makes a country rich. That mattered in the 1950s and 1960s, when many hoped one big infrastructure push could launch poor nations into growth. His slavery research, for all its controversy, established that Southern slavery was profitable and growing when the Civil War began. The market would not have ended it; politics and war did. He and Engerman also set out to record the achievements of enslaved Black Americans, which older histories had denied. In his later decades he turned to health. By linking military, pension and census records for tens of thousands of Union Army soldiers, his teams built public data for research on aging and chronic disease. The records show how sick nineteenth-century Americans were, and how much healthier later generations became. He argued that better food had changed the human body itself, and that stronger, healthier workers were a major source of economic growth, an idea that informs forecasts of health-care and pension costs. He also built institutions and people: a National Bureau of Economic Research program on the long-run American economy, Chicago's Center for Population Economics, and a generation of students including Claudia Goldin, the 2023 economics laureate. And with his wife, Enid, he spent three decades welcoming minority students into his home.

  • Railroads and American Economic Growth (1964) estimated that railroads added only a few percent to US output in 1890, overturning the belief that they were indispensable to American growth.[3],[9],[10]
  • Time on the Cross (1974), written with Stanley Engerman, found Southern slavery profitable and expanding before the Civil War: economics would not have ended it, political action did.[3],[8],[22]
  • He estimated that better nutrition explained roughly 30 percent of the growth in British income per person from 1790 to 1980, by giving workers more energy for work.[4]
  • His Union Army project made public the life histories of about 39,000 white and 6,000 Black Union soldiers, a lasting resource for research on aging and chronic disease.[2],[10]
  • His students, among them Claudia Goldin, Dora Costa and Robert Margo, became leading economic historians. Goldin won the economics prize in 2023.[9],[10],[23]
  • In 1982 he and Enid began the Fogel Dinner to welcome Black, Hispanic and Native American students to Chicago's business school. Booth continued the dinner after his death.[21]

Impact in numbers

Fogel's contribution is understanding, so we record no quantified impact claim. He changed how economic history is done, showing that counting and testing can overturn beliefs everyone takes for granted, and he trained many of the field's leaders. His railroad work warned against expecting any single project or invention to transform an economy. His slavery research showed the market would not have ended slavery, placing its end squarely on political choice and war, though its portrait of enslaved people's lives remains contested. His health research recast economic growth as partly a story about bodies: better food made people taller, healthier and able to work more, and healthier workers in turn fueled growth. These ideas inform research on aging, pensions and development, but no study measures lives saved or dollars gained because of his work rather than because of the farming, public-health and medical advances he described. Crediting those outcomes to him would double count the work of others.

EconomyHealthFundamental science

No number is given here on purpose. Some contributions cannot be counted honestly, and we would rather describe them than invent a figure.

The double edge

Fogel's most famous book caused real hurt and a long, bitter debate. Time on the Cross (1974) argued that enslaved workers were efficient, that their material living conditions compared well with those of Northern factory workers, that over a lifetime they received about 90 percent of the income they produced, and that whipping was less common than historians believed. Critics found serious errors in its data and reasoning, and some accused the authors of excusing slavery, although the authors acknowledged that enslaved people were exploited in ways statistics could not capture. Several claims have not held up: critics argued that counting whippings per worker hid how often the whip fell, later research credits better cotton varieties rather than the gang system for rising output, and Fogel himself later described a harsher reality for pregnant enslaved women. His 1989 book put the moral case against slavery at its center. Separately, before becoming a scholar he spent about eight years as a Communist Party organizer, leaving in 1956.

  • Moderate

    Time on the Cross and its picture of slavery

    The 1974 book claimed enslaved field hands were harder-working than their white counterparts, lived in material conditions comparable to Northern industrial workers, kept about 90 percent of the income they produced over a lifetime, and were whipped on average 0.7 times per hand per year. Critics said it was riddled with serious errors; Herbert Gutman, using the same evidence, calculated a whipping on average every 4.56 days. Some critics called the authors apologists for slavery.[9],[12],[13]

  • Minor

    Key claims later revised or overturned

    Later research by Alan Olmstead and Paul Rhode credits better cotton varieties, not the efficiency of the gang system, for rising cotton productivity. Fogel's own later anthropometric work led him to describe a much darker reality for pregnant enslaved women than Time on the Cross had, and his 1989 Without Consent or Contract made slavery's moral indictment central.[10],[14],[22]

  • Minor

    Eight years as a Communist Party organizer

    After Cornell he worked for about eight years as a professional organizer for the American Communist Party. He left in 1956, after Khrushchev's speech exposing Stalin's crimes and the Soviet invasion of Hungary, and later rejected communism.[9],[11]

Against the odds

Fogel was born in New York, and no source records antisemitism aimed at him personally. Persecution shaped his family before he was born. Both his parents were Jewish children in Odessa during the 1905 pogrom, the city's worst, in which more than 300 Jews were killed and the authorities were clearly complicit. His mother's family hid with a German friend who vowed to protect them, while Christian workers stood guard over his father's family. In 1922 his parents left Russia with their two-year-old son. In Constantinople typhus nearly killed his father and used up their money. A loan from the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society bought steerage passage, and they reached New York penniless, starting out in a Lower East Side tenement without electric light. He grew up during the Great Depression. American universities were slow to open to Jews. Before World War II Jewish professors were rare. In 1949 the University of Pennsylvania had just one Jewish tenured economist, Simon Kuznets, on a half-time appointment. Kuznets, who later supervised Fogel's doctorate, left Johns Hopkins because, one historian writes, the Hopkins president did not want him on the faculty. Fogel met prejudice through his marriage too. In 1949 he married Enid Morgan, a Black woman, when about 30 states still had laws against interracial marriage. Some New York restaurants would not seat Black diners, and strangers stared when the couple held hands on the subway. Decades later, critics of his slavery research accused him of racism, which troubled him.

  • 1905

    Persecution

    Both his parents, then about seven, lived through the October 1905 Odessa pogrom, the city's worst, in which more than 300 Jews were killed while the authorities stood by or took part. His mother's family hid with a German friend; Christian workers guarded his father's family.[15],[20]

  • 1922

    Exile

    His parents left Russia with his two-year-old brother in 1922. Typhus nearly killed his father in Constantinople and exhausted their money; a Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society loan paid for steerage, and they arrived in New York penniless.[2],[6],[7]

  • —

    Poverty

    The family began in a Lower East Side tenement without electric lights, on a first wage Fogel described as below today's minimum. He grew up during the Great Depression, though his father's meat business later prospered.[2],[6],[7]

  • —

    Discrimination

    Context rather than a barrier he is recorded as meeting: before World War II Jews were rarely hired as US professors, in 1949 Penn's only tenured Jewish economist, Simon Kuznets, held a half-time post, and Kuznets, who became his doctoral adviser, left Johns Hopkins because, a historian writes, its president did not want him there.[18]

  • 1949

    Discrimination

    He married Enid Cassandra Morgan, an African American, in 1949. They faced segregated restaurants and stares on the subway. In 1967, 16 states still banned interracial marriage, and 14 others had repealed such bans only in the previous 15 years.[9],[19],[21]

Jewish background

Both parents JewishRelationship to Jewish identity not documented

Both parents were Jews from Odessa. His father's father was a kosher butcher, and his mother's father was a Zionist who held banned meetings at home. The family left Russia in 1922, and a loan from the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society paid their passage on to New York. His older brother, the poet Ephim Fogel, later wrote some of the earliest literary responses to the Holocaust. As a boy Robert studied sculpture at the 92nd Street YMHA, and in 1966 he recorded his parents' memories of the 1905 pogrom. No source describes his religious practice or how he saw his own Jewish identity. He married Enid Morgan, an Episcopal Sunday-school teacher.[2],[7],[15],[16],[17],[22]

Key dates

  1. July 1, 1926

    Born in New York City, the second son of Jewish immigrants from Odessa. (Nobel's facts page gives 1927; his own Nobel autobiography says 1926.)[1],[2],[8],[9]

  2. 1944

    Graduated from Stuyvesant High School, one of New York's public science high schools.[9],[12]

  3. 1948

    Graduated from Cornell as a history major, then spent about eight years as a Communist Party organizer.[2],[11],[22]

  4. 1949

    Married Enid Cassandra Morgan, whom he met while she led Harlem Youth for Wallace.[2],[7],[9]

  5. 1956

    Left the Communist Party and entered Columbia's graduate program in economics.[7],[11]

  6. 1963

    Earned his PhD at Johns Hopkins under Simon Kuznets.[2]

  7. 1964

    Published Railroads and American Economic Growth and joined the University of Chicago.[3],[8]

  8. 1974

    Published Time on the Cross with Stanley Engerman, igniting a fierce national debate over slavery.[9],[13]

  9. 1978

    While at Harvard, founded the NBER program on the Development of the American Economy.[8],[10]

  10. 1981

    Returned to Chicago as Walgreen Professor of American Institutions, heading a new Center for Population Economics created for his research.[2],[10]

  11. 1991

    The National Institute on Aging funded his Union Army project on early life and later health.[10]

  12. October 12, 1993

    Awarded the economics prize, shared with Douglass North, for renewing economic history.[1],[3]

  13. 2007

    Enid Fogel, his wife since 1949, died.[9],[11]

  14. June 11, 2013

    Died in Oak Lawn, Illinois, aged 86, while still teaching at Chicago.[1],[9],[10]

Sources

  1. 1.Robert W. Fogel - Facts · NobelPrize.org (Nobel Prize Outreach)
  2. 2.Robert W. Fogel - Biographical · NobelPrize.org (The Nobel Foundation), 1993
  3. 3.The Prize in Economic Sciences 1993 - Press release (12 October 1993) · NobelPrize.org (Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences), 1993
  4. 4.Economic Growth, Population Theory, and Physiology: The Bearing of Long-Term Processes on the Making of Economic Policy (Nobel Lecture, 9 December 1993) · NobelPrize.org (The Nobel Foundation), 1993
  5. 5.Award ceremony speech, Prize in Economic Sciences 1993 (Lennart Jorberg) · NobelPrize.org (The Nobel Foundation), 1993
  6. 6.Robert W. Fogel - Interview (Lindau, September 2004) · NobelPrize.org (Nobel Prize Outreach), 2004
  7. 7.A Life of Learning (Charles Homer Haskins Lecture for 1996), ACLS Occasional Paper No. 34 · American Council of Learned Societies, 1996
  8. 8.Robert Fogel, won Nobel Prize in Economics, 1926-2013 (Ethan Grove) · University of Chicago News, 2013
  9. 9.Robert W. Fogel, Nobel-Winning Economist, Dies at 86 (Robert D. Hershey Jr.) · The New York Times, 2013
  10. 10.Robert W. Fogel: Visionary economic historian, generous mentor, eternal optimist (Dora Costa, Claudia Goldin and Robert A. Margo), EH.Net In Memoriam (Wayback Machine snapshot) · Economic History Association (EH.Net), 2013
  11. 11.Robert Fogel (1926-2013) (Stanley Engerman), Perspectives on History · American Historical Association, 2013
  12. 12.The human equation (Lydialyle Gibson) · The University of Chicago Magazine, 2007
  13. 13.Review essay: Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery (Thomas Weiss), Project 2001: Significant Works in Economic History · EH.Net (Economic History Association), 2001
  14. 14.Robert William Fogel (1926-2013): A Birthday Appreciation (Art Carden) · The Daily Economy (American Institute for Economic Research), 2020
  15. 15.The Odessa pogrom of 1905: First hand testimony of Harry and Elizabeth Fogel (Becky Fogel Anderson; Wayback Machine snapshot) · JewishGen Odessa KehilaLinks
  16. 16.Poetic Justice (Amy Oringel) · Jewish Book Council, 2021
  17. 17.Robert Fogel (1926-2013) · Jewish Virtual Library
  18. 18.MIT's Openness to Jewish Economists (E. Roy Weintraub), CHOPE Working Paper 2013-05 · Center for the History of Political Economy, Duke University, 2013
  19. 19.Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1 (1967) · Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, 1967
  20. 20.Odesa, Ukraine (from the Encyclopaedia Judaica) · Jewish Virtual Library, 2007
  21. 21.A Welcoming Home (Sam Jemielity) · Chicago Booth Magazine, 2016
  22. 22.Nobel Laureate Robert W. Fogel · The University of Chicago Booth School of Business
  23. 23.Claudia Goldin - Facts · NobelPrize.org (Nobel Prize Outreach)

Fact-checked on September 24, 2026 by a separate AI fact-checking pass that re-opened the sources, with 6 corrections made. How we check

Suggest a correction